Queering the MNAR European Art Gallery: Difference between revisions

From Artists Curated Registry
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 43: Line 43:
KillingoftheInnocents-MasteroftheKrainburgAltar.jpg|'''Killing of the Innocents''', author: ''Master of the Krainburg Altar'', currently in the National Romanian Museum of Art Collection, photo by (c) Lumi Rațiu, 2026; '''Queered role:''' gender-violence, institutional silence, state-condoned violence, biopolitics; '''Queered guidance:''' The work presents the biblical quoted episode of killing the babies. The museal label often describe the narrative without reference to the gender-violence, maternal trauma and the male-led criminality, often perpetuated against the weakest in a society, or the state-condoned violence, a violence that the state permits, tolerates, or fails to prevent. The massacre described in this artwork targets a category of people defined by age and sex, making the children's bodies objects of sovereign calculation, a form of biopower, a means of controlling, organizing, or otherwise governing large groups of people by placing limitations and controls on their bodies.
KillingoftheInnocents-MasteroftheKrainburgAltar.jpg|'''Killing of the Innocents''', author: ''Master of the Krainburg Altar'', currently in the National Romanian Museum of Art Collection, photo by (c) Lumi Rațiu, 2026; '''Queered role:''' gender-violence, institutional silence, state-condoned violence, biopolitics; '''Queered guidance:''' The work presents the biblical quoted episode of killing the babies. The museal label often describe the narrative without reference to the gender-violence, maternal trauma and the male-led criminality, often perpetuated against the weakest in a society, or the state-condoned violence, a violence that the state permits, tolerates, or fails to prevent. The massacre described in this artwork targets a category of people defined by age and sex, making the children's bodies objects of sovereign calculation, a form of biopower, a means of controlling, organizing, or otherwise governing large groups of people by placing limitations and controls on their bodies.
PortraitofcountertenorCarloBroschicalledFarinelli-JacopoAmigoni.jpg|'''Portrait of countertenor Carlo Broschi, called Farinelli''', autor: Jacopo Amigoni, oil on canvas, ', currently in the National Romanian Museum of Art Collection, photo by (c) Lumi Rațiu, 2026; '''Queered role:''' sexual mutilation, male genital mutilation, survivor, alterated biology, non-conforming, vocal androgyny, non-binary precursor; '''Queered guidance:''' The work depicts the famous 18th-century castrato singer, Carlo Broschi, who was castrated before puberty with the aim of enhancing his vocal range, spanning soprano and alto. This physically separated him from conventional male or female categories and severly impacted his social and intimate life. The 1994 film about Carlo Broschi heavily leans into this by portraying him as an almost mythological, sexually fluid being who shares intimate physical relationships with women alongside his brother, who acts as his anatomical surrogate. His figure is used by modern curators to link historical figures to contemporary non-binary identities without erasing historical context.
PortraitofcountertenorCarloBroschicalledFarinelli-JacopoAmigoni.jpg|'''Portrait of countertenor Carlo Broschi, called Farinelli''', autor: Jacopo Amigoni, oil on canvas, ', currently in the National Romanian Museum of Art Collection, photo by (c) Lumi Rațiu, 2026; '''Queered role:''' sexual mutilation, male genital mutilation, survivor, alterated biology, non-conforming, vocal androgyny, non-binary precursor; '''Queered guidance:''' The work depicts the famous 18th-century castrato singer, Carlo Broschi, who was castrated before puberty with the aim of enhancing his vocal range, spanning soprano and alto. This physically separated him from conventional male or female categories and severly impacted his social and intimate life. The 1994 film about Carlo Broschi heavily leans into this by portraying him as an almost mythological, sexually fluid being who shares intimate physical relationships with women alongside his brother, who acts as his anatomical surrogate. His figure is used by modern curators to link historical figures to contemporary non-binary identities without erasing historical context.
StJulianaMartyrdom-Cassone.jpg|'''St Juliana Martyrdom - Cassone''' (Wood box), wood box and oil on canvas, author: Unknown, provenience: the Carol I Royal Collection, photo by (c) Lumi Rațiu, 2026; '''Queered role:''' marriage refusal, religious celibacy as female agency, ; '''Queered guidance:''' The work depicts St Juliana, a woman who invokes religious consecration to avoid a forced marriage and asserts her autonomy, even at the cost of martyrdom. Such examples in history that can be considered a religious celibacy as a form of female agency can be researched also into Saint Agnes — rejected all suitors because she considered herself "betrothed to Christ.", Saint Lucy — dedicated her virginity to God and refused marriage, Saint Catherine of Alexandria — refused an imperial marriage proposal.
StJulianaMartyrdom-Cassone.jpg|'''St Juliana Martyrdom - Cassone''' (Wood box), wood box and oil on canvas, author: Unknown, provenience: the Carol I Royal Collection, photo by (c) Lumi Rațiu, 2026; '''Queered role:''' marriage refusal, religious celibacy as female agency, forced marriage, historical forced marriage; '''Queered guidance:''' The work depicts St Juliana, a woman who invokes religious consecration to avoid a forced marriage and asserts her autonomy, even at the cost of martyrdom. Such examples in history that can be considered a religious celibacy as a form of female agency can be researched also into Saint Agnes — rejected all suitors because she considered herself "betrothed to Christ.", Saint Lucy — dedicated her virginity to God and refused marriage, Saint Catherine of Alexandria — refused an imperial marriage proposal.
</gallery>
</gallery>
<br>
<br>

Revision as of 12:51, 14 July 2026

Introduction

Traditionally, art museums in Romania, with a little but perhaps insufficient exception at the national museum of contemporary art, actively avoid a critical discussion of methodological aspects of a queer perspective in interpreting, exhibiting, and organizing museum collections, preserving museum’s conservatory approaches in supporting “heteronormative” narratives that consolidate heterosexuality as a norm within social and cultural life. There is a need to investigate what non-normative or queer relations exist around art museum displays and collections, rethinking them through and with (de)colonial and other historical entanglements while not simply dwelling in the past but instead making connections to our present and futures. There are no queering strategy to make their collection more representative of queer people, or better represent gender and identity-related diversity. Attention should be give: queer should not be understood merely as a credible practice for museums that are officially labeled “gay” such as the Schwules Museum* in Berlin. This would be just the old practice of demarcation and segregation.
We ask ourselves:

  • Is queer curating something missing from the general curating practice, not just about sexuality, but more broadly a social aesthetics through which we might rethink society?
  • Are queer artists equally and/or correctly represented in museum collections?
  • Are the museums descriptive texts and brochures related to the works in their collections sensitive enough to queer and identity issues?



Funding transparency:


This research has been made possible through an Individual Mobility 2025-2026 funded by the Creative Europe programme of the European Union and implemented by Goethe-Institut. This publication was produced with the financial assistance of the European Union. The views expressed herein can in no way be taken to reflect the official opinion of the European Union.

Queering the museum


Documentation & Research carried out by Lumi Rațiu and Alex Bodea, Bucharest, MNAR European Art Gallery, July 2026.
The National Museum of Art of Romania hosts Romania’s premier collection of European art: the European Art Gallery. Paintings by Domenico Veneziano, Jacopo Bassano, Bronzino, Tintoretto and Luca Giordano tell a story of Italian art throughout nearly four centuries, while those of Rembrandt and Jan Davidsz de Heem remind visitors of the Golden Age of Dutch art. Flemish art of the 17th century is particularly well represented through works by Pieter Paul Rubens, Pieter van Mol, Pieter Brueghel the Younger and Jan Brueghel the Elder. Spanish school highlights focus on three El Greco paintings illustrative of his career development. The German school includes works by Lucas Cranach the Elder and Hans von Aachen, whereas the French one brings center stage paintings by famous 19th century artists such as Claude Monet, Paul Signac and Alfred Sisley alongside sculptures by Auguste Rodin, Camille Claudel and Antoine Bourdelle.

Positive aspects of the visit:

  • Some of the works are digitalised by the museum and can be visualised online, at high resolution here: [1]
  • The labels are trilingual and comprise the details on technique
  • The works are in a good conservation state
  • From time to time there are works taken out from storage and shown to visitors, alongside specialised talks about them
  • There are chairs and sofas to accommodate visitors, in almost every room, however the antique sofas, still in use for visitors, are in poor condition, requiring restoration

Ensaddening findings:

  • There are only two paintings created by women painters, represented in the Gallery.
  • The elevators ensuring the access to people with disabilities does not work.
  • There is no room or facility provided for parent-with-child.
  • There are no references to queer issues-aspects, neither in the museum or the museum bookshop.
  • Some of the room attendants were on loudly phone-speaking with their relatives, talking about personal or family issues.



Recommended Queer Guide of the MNAR European Art Gallery, Bucharest




Copyrights and Reproduction of research findings and materials


The views expressed herein and all related audio-video-photo materials are under copyright licence, restricted to non-commercial use only and requiring full attribution to prevent infringement. Failing to credit the creators can lead to plagiarism accusations, and missing required credits on licensed materials breaches copyright terms.

_____________________________________________________________________